Is the Military Draft Unethical - 574 Words

A nation as a whole is only as strong as its military. It has been stated that, â€Å"in order to defend themselves from external threats, nations assemble militaries that are tasked with preserving national security†(Military Draft 1). The method chosen by United States to assemble a military force has been the subject of ethical debates since the introduction of the military draft in 1861, during the Civil War. Dictionary.com defines ethical as something, â€Å"being in accordance with the rules or standards for right conduct or practice†(1). A thorough investigation finds that there are three major ethical dilemmas that are often debated pertaining to the military draft. These dilemmas include the draft’s effect on civic pride, the disproportionate number of minorities, and the strength of the military. When the draft was first introduced, the government envisioned it as a way to instill a sense of civic pride in society. However, the citizens of the United St ates saw it as an intrusion on their rights. Widespread public opposition concerning the military draft was seen throughout the nation ranging from draftees refusing to report for duty, to the many large well-known protests. James Robbins states, â€Å"a conscripted military would not be more just; it would simply universalize injustice by removing individual choice from the equation†(qtd. in Military Draft 6). The injustice of removing an individual’s choice is unconstitutional and is intrusive to person’s rights. ThisShow MoreRelatedThe soldier is the Army. No army is better than its soldiers. The Soldier is also a citizen. In1100 Words   |  5 Pagesvolunteer in the worlds greatest military; and put their lives on the line for something that they believe is a moral obligation. But, think of some other countries, that have conscription (the practice of ordering people by law to serve in the armed forces) laws. We as a nation have some laws on conscription, and if you are male and above the age of 18 you have already signed the slip of paper stating that in the time of war; if our great nation re-instated the draft then there is a great chance youRead MoreAnalysis Of The Movie If I Die 1713 Words   |  7 PagesThe war in Vietnam was unlike many wars that the United States has become involved in with military action. The Vietnam War is one that the United States had no direct reason to become a part of the conflict. Even though we weren’t directly attacked by Vietnam to initiate American involvement in the war, the leadership of the American government, at the time, thought it was necessary for the United States to get involved to help stop the spread of communism. Many people disagreed with the decisionRead MoreThe Death Of The Vietnam War Essay1736 Words   |  7 Pagesjustify the amount of unethical decisions and situations that were allowed to take place. In 1961, under President Kennedy, 100 Special Forces troops were sent to South Vietnam and by 1963, just two years later, U.S military advisors and Special Forces had increased to 21,000 troops. We will soon see that this is just the beginning and in my paper I will outline the full record of events all the way to the end of the war, including the reasons for U.S involvement, unethical decisions that were madeRead MoreNearly One-Fifth Of The U.S Military Is Female, However1319 Words   |  6 PagesNearly one-fifth of the U.S military is female, however certain jobs are not eligible for women. Is it believed that women are not considered for front-line combat and Special Forces positions. Opponents argue that women are physically not capable of being effective for troops and would distract men making the military less effective. However women are fully capable of becoming troops the only thing holding them back is the stereotype that they are not physically capable of handing combat roles.Read MoreEssay on Military Women Should NOT Be Allowed in Combat Positions1724 Words   |  7 Pages     Ã‚  Ã‚  Ã‚  Ã‚   In late 1990 and early 1991, thousands of American women marched off to the desert sands of the Middle East to serve in a war that brought women closer to combat than ever before. Although restricting women from occupying military jobs that would put them into direct contact with the enemy can be interpreted as a form of sex discrimination, as a female veteran of Operation Desert Storm, I believe that the restriction should remain as it is. Lifting this ban would not be a strategic moveRead MoreEssay about Womens Roles in the Military1279 Words   |  6 Pages Womens Roles in the Military Before World War I, women assisted the military during wartime mainly as nurses and helpers. Some women, however, did become involved in battles. Molly Pitcher, a Revolutionary War water carrier, singlehandedly kept a cannon in action after a artillery crew had been disabled. During the Revolutionary and the Civil War, a few women disguised themselves as men and took part in hand-to-hand combat. The first enlisted women served in World War I as telephone and radioRead MoreFreedom, Liberty, and Independence 1302 Words   |  6 Pagesbetween the rights of individual freedoms and liberties, and the political interests of the country. Jackson and his fellow Democrats deemed that the continued success of the nation could be achieved thru the stern efforts of keeping the formation of unethical and immoral private establishments at a minimum. (W-20, 21) Henry Clay was a member of the Whig Party, who believed in the idea of a strong central government, with the majority of power resting in the hands of Congress. Clay believed that moreRead MoreThe Vietnam War And Its Effects On America2000 Words   |  8 Pagesthe war was initially under the false pretense of simplistic and swift victory caused by the positive outcome of the two previous global wars. However, this valiant feeling soon deteriorated into means of protests. Americans soon discovered many unethical actions carried out by the government in order to proceed with the war. Near the start of the war, South Vietnam’s democratic, albeit extremely futile, leader Ngo Dinh Diem was assassinated because American forces did not trust the corrupted politicianRead MoreEthics and Morals in Our Society612 Words   |  2 Pagestheir profession. Moral relates to the individuals own principles regarding right and wrong. Being in the military, I have an ethical code to abide by a nd that is doing the right thing even when no one is looking. Professionalism is very important in my line of work because if I do something wrong, not only does the organization get a bad name; but also my family name. Being in the military, we are all held to a higher standard and it is very important we set up the framework for acceptable behaviorRead MoreMy Grandfather, By Edwin Richard Constant Essay2126 Words   |  9 Pagesthat any U.S Military flying program required two years of college. Upon graduation in 1963, my grandfather had got a job as a quality assurance engineer at a machine tool company that manufactured components for military aircraft, allowing him to have a girlfriend and a 1960 Alfa Romeo Guillia Spyder sports car. In April of 1964, my grandfather was brought into his boss’s office and was told to answer the phone when it rang, and he was left alone in the room when the phone rang a Military Sergeant’s